DIET & LIFESTYLE

DISCOVER HOW TO HEAL

Why Joyful Belly Isn't A Member Of Nama

Written by John Immel, Asheville, NC
blank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewSign in to review this article
Print Why Joyful Belly Isn
Share on Social Media
Share Content with Friends & Clients

Click one of the buttons above, or cut and paste the following link to share this page with your network. This link will automatically track your referrals to Joyful Belly:

Share URL for Why Joyful Belly Isn't a Member of NAMA

Copy Link

About Sharing Content & Referrals.

Credentials, Accreditation

Since 2008, the Joyful Belly School of Ayurveda has provided premium Ayurveda education for clinicians. Joyful Belly is licensed to teach Ayurveda by the state of North Carolina. We are recognized / accredited by the following associations: We are not, however, a member of the National Ayurveda Medical Association (NAMA).

NAMA exists for schools that cannot meet government licensing requirements. As NAMA has no standing with the U.S. government, NAMA can offer no added legal basis for practice.

Joyful Belly Ayurveda is already a licensed college by the state of North Carolina, making NAMA membership unnecessary.

Our Ayurveda Health Counselor Course was approved by NAMA as of March of 2020. However, we did not accept NAMA recognition because of 1) NAMA's low clinical standard (by comparison the American Herbalists Guild requires 400 hours of clinical experience), a minimum to ensure safe delivery of Ayurveda to clients, 2) conflicts of interests in NAMA leadership (see below), and 3) requirements that go against World Health Organization Standards for the profession (see below).

Educational Freedom for Students

We stand with NAASC, an association of Ayurveda schools, in providing competency based education, rejecting any encroachment by associations on method of education delivery. Assessment of competency is the only valid measure of accreditation, and is the best way to reduce student cost and makes Ayurveda accessible to a wider audience.

Legal Status of Ayurveda

Ayurvedic students can, and most do, legally see clients and practice Ayurveda without joining AAPNA, NAMA, or any of the above mentioned 3rd party associations, because Ayurveda is an unlicensed profession in the United States. Joyful Belly Ayurveda will give you a diploma upon graduation, and you will be able to see clients. Students should not let associations intimidate them (frequent among NAMA schools) into joining. Instead, graduates should join associations that commit to serving their needs and provide demonstrable benefits. The greatest need of students after graduating is clinical support - an area where NAMA continues to underperform as they operate to protect the schools that fund them (not their clinician members).

Find out more about the legal status of Ayurveda here.

Profession wide, schools and practitioners are moving away from NAMA for the following reasons:

  • NAMA's attempts to assess competency creates conflict of interest with its ability to represent clinicians - often pitting NAMA against the very clinicians it seeks to represent and leading to an adversarial culture, as competency assessment leads to higher tuition costs. In most licensed professions, representation of clinicians and assessment of competency are handled by two separate, unaffiliated associations.
  • In 2018 NAMA tried to license their form of Ayurveda in Colorado without contacting any of the Ayurveda schools or associations to form a consensus. Had the licensing passed, students would have been forced into NAMA's sole vision for the Ayurveda community. Students would not be able to attend Ayurveda school online, for example, and education costs for our program would have jumped near to $22,000. 2/3's of the schools in the Ayurveda community would have had to shut their doors forever. Requirements for onsite training protect the revenues of brick and mortar institutions that fund NAMA, but do not lead to provable differences in practitioner competency. Instead, the science shows that use of technology improves learning rates over traditional classroom settings..
  • NAMA allows schools to fund them, and serve as officers and board members in their by-laws. This causes a conflict of interest with their claim to represent their practitioner members, leading to policy decisions that benefit the schools that fund NAMA instead. For example, school officers of NAMA directly benefit from requirements that raise tuition costs or restrict competition.
  • NAMA favors and promotes school owners as presenters at conferences instead of their member clinicians. They select presenters on the basis of spiritual charm without any reference to clinical success rates. New members do not have objective criteria or a fair chance to become presenters.
  • NAMA has a strong focus on protecting and promoting Vedic culture, rather than health outcomes. At Joyful Belly, the health of the client always comes first. Patient centered care means focusing on the culture of the client, not the medicine. We take the view that Ayurveda should serve our clients, rather than the other way around. We approach classical texts with a critical eye and academic rigor, aiming not at tradition, but growth and evolution through novel research. At Joyful Belly, authenticity in medicine is measured by clinical outcomes.
  • NAMA considers Ayurveda to be a spiritual paradigm & consciousness philosophy (see their mission statement), rather than a medical paradigm that can be separated from Vedic religion. This evangelical focus alienates clients who don't have a Vedic religious background, makes Ayurveda inaccessible to outsiders, and leads the public to believe Ayurveda is a faith healing practice, rather than a clinical one. It causes many in the medical profession to reject Ayurveda entirely.
    Read: Protecting Religious Neutrality in Ayurveda
  • At the association level, we advocate for a more professional, clinical approach (similar to acupuncture and chiropractors), one that leaves individual practitioners the freedom to incorporate any spiritual tradition they choose. This universal approach reaches a more diverse audience, increasing the impact of graduates in their mission to improve public health, and to thrive financially.
  • NAMA and NAMA schools increase membership by scaring new students into believing that unless they get a membership, they will be cut off from having a legitimate or even legal practice forever. However, NAMA has no authority with the government. Most Ayurveda professionals do not consider NAMA approval a reliable measure of practitioner competency - as NAMA does not audit schools or graduate placement. Students who feel they need to join NAMA have usually been convinced of this by one of their funding member schools or NAMA representatives directly.
  • NAMA claims it is working on 'legalizing Ayurveda' through licensing. However, Ayurveda is already legal. Licensing does not increase legality, it restricts it. NAMA is trying to do the opposite of what it claims- and use licensing to acquire power over the profession of Ayurveda. Licensing exists to protect the public, not NAMA. While Acupuncture is a licensed profession, Chinese Medicine as a whole remains unlicensed. Joyful Belly supports licensing of panchkarma, only, not the whole practice of Ayurveda.
  • NAMA is more expensive than other associations. If students wish to apply for certification with NAMA after graduating from Joyful Belly, they pay to take their board certification exam, expensive annual dues, and school evaluation fees as well.

NAMA's Opposition to WHO Standards

NAMA's membership requirement to teach astrology goes against the standards set by the World Health Organization (WHO), is not in compliance with the Indian ministry of alternative health (AYUSH), and unacceptable to most medical professionals.

Ayurveda practitioners in India generally resent NAMA's abandonment of classical Ayurveda in the West, and their shift away from research and clinical outcomes towards New Age or miraculous healing.

At Joyful Belly we teach Ayurveda as a medicine alternative with demonstrable clinical outcomes, and support associations who believe the same. We ensure that medicine should be accessible to people of all social groups and faiths. We follow the WHO recommended scope of training, which recognizes Ayurveda's potential to reach a broader audience.

The level of training at Joyful Belly far exceeds NAMA's membership requirements for an Ayurveda Health Counselor program, with the exception of religious content that could alienate and isolate students of other faiths. Our graduates are known for this higher level of training.

To represent our diverse students and clients, we choose to align with associations that can represent all individuals who wish to participate in the Ayurveda profession, regardless of their cultural or religious identity.

Client Perspective

It is interesting to note that the public is generally not familiar with the subtleties of certification or licensing for Ayurveda in the United States. A few times in my Ayurveda career I have been asked about my schooling, but never about certification.

Reach Out With Questions

We are happy to answer any additional questions students have about the certification process. Please write admissions@joyfulbelly.com.

Note: None of the certifying bodies in the United States operate internationally.

READ MORE ON THIS TOPIC
Why AABC?
Should Clinicians Join NAPA Ayurveda?
 
LikesMy Saved Articles | Most Popular

About John Joseph Immel

About the Author

John Immel, the founder of Joyful Belly, teaches people how to have a healthy diet and lifestyle with Ayurveda biocharacteristics. His approach to Ayurveda is clinical, yet exudes an ease which many find enjoyable and insightful. John also directs Joyful Belly's School of Ayurveda, offering professional clinical training in Ayurveda for over 15 years.

John's interest in Ayurveda and specialization in digestive tract pathology was inspired by a complex digestive disorder acquired from years of international travel, as well as public service work in South Asia. John's commitment to the detailed study of digestive disorders reflects his zeal to get down to the roots of the problem. His hope and belief in the capacity of each & every client to improve their quality of life is nothing short of a personal passion. John's creativity in the kitchen and delight in cooking for others comes from his family oriented upbringing. In addition to his certification in Ayurveda, John holds a bachelor's degree in mathematics from Harvard University.

John enjoys sharing Ayurveda within the context of his Catholic roots, and finds Ayurveda gives him an opportunity to participate in the healing mission of the Church. Jesus expressed God's love by feeding and healing the sick. That kindness is the fundamental ministry of Ayurveda as well. Outside of work, John enjoys spending time with his wife and 7 kids, and pursuing his love of theology, philosophy, and language.

Read more

STUDY AYURVEDA

Questions, Comments & Impressions of 'why joyful belly isn't a member of nama'?

Is there something else you'd like to know about 'why joyful belly isn't a member of nama'?

5 likes
blank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewblank start reviewSign in to review this article

Join Joyful Belly.

Want our top Ayurvedic recipes and health tips?
Subscribe to our free newsletter!
If you are already a member please sign in here. Forgot your password?
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. The information and products on this website are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

© 2024 Joyful Belly Ayurveda Inc., All rights reserved.
Asheville, North Carolina
1